Level Up Your Storytelling – Turn Ideas Into Impact

WordPress Website Maintenance Checklist: 12 Tasks to Review

WordPress Website Maintenance Checklist: 12 Tasks to Review

Quick Overview

A WordPress website maintenance checklist should tell you what work gets done, when it happens, who owns it, and how you can verify it. These 12 tasks will help you review your current maintenance plan, ask better questions of your provider, and protect the parts of your site that donors, members, and program participants depend on.

What professional WordPress maintenance looks like

Start with the journeys people need to complete on your website. A donor needs to make a gift and receive a confirmation. A member needs to sign in. An event attendee needs to register and get the right details. Those are the steps your team should be able to test when an update or incident affects the site.

Ask your provider or internal team to document what they maintain, who receives alerts, and how they escalate problems. A useful maintenance report tells you what changed, what was tested, and which issues still need a decision.

The 12 maintenance tasks to review with your provider

1. Verify backups and test recovery

Confirm which parts of the site are backed up, where those backups are stored, and how long they’re retained. The backup schedule should reflect how often the site changes and how much recent work your organization could afford to lose.

Ask for the date and result of the last restore test. A test should confirm that the restored site loads and that critical pages, content, and workflows are available. If your donation or registration platform stores records separately, confirm who is responsible for recovering that data.

Ask your provider: When did you last restore our site in a test environment, and what did you verify after the restore?

2. Review security scans and alerts

Agree on which alerts your team receives and who reviews them. The maintenance record should show which issues were investigated, what was resolved, and what still requires action. For example, a vulnerability alert might lead to an update, a temporary change, or a plan to replace a plugin that is no longer maintained.

Ask your provider: What did the most recent security review find, and what action did you take?

3. Check uptime monitoring and escalation

Confirm which URLs the provider monitors and where alerts go. A homepage may load while a separate registration or donation page is unavailable. If a critical workflow depends on another platform, find out what your provider can monitor and who contacts that platform when there’s an issue.

For each outage, ask for the start and end times, the pages or services affected, and any follow-up work.

Ask your provider: Who gets notified when our site goes down, and what happens if an alert comes in outside normal support hours?

4. Update WordPress, themes, and plugins with a testing plan

Keep a record of updates and decide which changes require testing in a staging environment, a private copy of the site. Give extra attention to changes that affect forms, payments, logins, or integrations. Agree on how urgent security updates are handled and what recovery options are available if an update causes a problem.

Ask your provider: Which updates do you test before deployment, and how would you recover if an update broke a critical feature?

5. Test critical workflows after updates

Check the live site after changes are deployed. A page can look right even when the form, confirmation email, or handoff to another tool fails. Use an approved test account or test mode where available. For a donation form, for example, check the form on mobile, complete the approved test, and confirm the expected receipt or record.

Keep a short list of the workflows and devices that need checking after each type of update.

Ask your provider: Which workflows did you test after the last update, and how did you confirm they worked?

6. Refresh caches when changes need to reach visitors

Caching helps pages load quickly by serving saved versions. After a significant update or content change, check whether any site or hosting cache needs refreshing. Then open the page as a logged-out visitor and verify the public version, especially for event dates, campaign links, or application instructions.

Ask your provider: How do you verify that visitors can see an important change after it’s published?

7. Review database health before cleanup

Database maintenance may help when outdated temporary records, recurring errors, or unexpected growth are causing problems. Ask the provider to identify what they plan to change, review whether any records are still needed, and confirm recovery is available before cleanup. Account for records your organization needs to retain, such as form entries or transaction history.

Ask your provider: What prompted the last database cleanup, and how did you protect records we still need?

8. Review unused plugins and themes

Keep an inventory of major plugins, what they do, and who owns their licenses or renewals. Investigate plugins connected to features you’ve retired. Before removing one, check whether any forms, page templates, or integrations still depend on it and whether it stores records your team needs.

Ask your provider: Which plugins are essential to our site, and which can we safely retire?

9. Track the performance of key pages

Choose pages that matter to your organization, such as a donation landing page, an application page, or an event registration page. Review their mobile experience and compare performance over time. Tools such as PageSpeed Insights can help diagnose issues. Pair those results with practical checks, such as whether the form is easy to reach and use on a phone.

Ask your provider: Which pages are you tracking, what changed, and which improvement would help visitors most?

10. Audit user accounts and permissions

Review who has administrator access and whether their role still requires it. Remove or downgrade access when staff leave, vendors finish an engagement, or temporary work ends. Include the connected services your team uses to run the site, such as hosting and forms, when they fall within the review scope.

Ask your provider: Who has administrator access today, and who handles access changes when someone leaves?

11. Review suspicious login activity

Clarify who investigates unusual sign-ins or repeated failed attempts. Ask which protections are in place, such as multifactor authentication for administrator accounts, and what the response process looks like if an account may have been compromised.

Ask your provider: What would trigger an investigation, and who would notify us if an administrator account were affected?

12. Check that priority pages can be found and used

After publishing a key page or changing a URL, confirm that internal links point directly to the intended destination. Check that pages intended for search are eligible to be indexed, and review relevant Google Search Console alerts. For important content changes, also check for obvious accessibility barriers such as missing form labels or unclear link text.

Ask your provider: What did the last review uncover on our most important pages, and who owns the fixes?

How to set a WordPress maintenance schedule

Use the checklist as a scope of work, then assign a cadence to each task. The right schedule depends on how often the site changes, the impact of an outage, and who can respond.

When What to review
Ongoing or on an agreed schedule Uptime alerts, security alerts, and backup jobs
Before and after significant changes Update testing, recovery readiness, mobile checks, and any affected forms or integrations
During a regular maintenance review Update history, backup status, access changes, site performance, and unresolved issues
Before a major campaign or event Donation or registration flows, key landing pages, support contacts, and escalation coverage

Include a named owner for each item. If your provider handles the website and your team owns the donation platform, agree on who checks the full donation journey and follows up when it fails.

What a maintenance report should show

A useful report gives your team enough information to make decisions. Ask for:

  • The reporting period and the updates or fixes completed.
  • Backup status and the date and result of the most recent restore test.
  • Outages or security issues, what was affected, and how the team responded.
  • The critical workflows tested and any accessibility or performance issues found.
  • Open items, their owners, and the next action or decision.

If you’re reviewing an existing contract, ask your provider to walk you through the last report and one issue they handled. Compare the work shown with the scope you agreed to. For help budgeting for any gaps, see our nonprofit website maintenance cost guide.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between hosting and maintenance?

Hosting provides the infrastructure that runs your website. A managed hosting plan may also cover tasks such as backups or software updates. Ask who owns testing, incident response, content changes, and support for the forms and integrations your organization relies on.

Can our team maintain WordPress in-house?

Yes, if your team has time, clear ownership, and the skills to handle testing and recovery. You can also split the work. For example, your communications team might own routine content updates while a technical provider handles software maintenance, recovery, and troubleshooting.

What should we review before renewing a maintenance contract?

Start with the last report, the most recent restore test, and the list of workflows covered after updates. Confirm how support requests are prioritized, when coverage applies, and which work would be quoted separately.

Need help maintaining your WordPress site?

Black Digital helps nonprofits and associations review their current setup and define the support their websites need. Explore our WordPress website maintenance services.

Table of Contents

Let’s discuss your next success

We turn ideas into impact.
Let’s build something that drives real results for your brand.

Agency

Services

Partners

Work

Level Up Your Storytelling – Turn Ideas Into Impact